IdeaWell

Project ideas from Hacker News discussions.

Apple has added persistent 'ads' to iOS, and it's driving users crazy

Original Article

Hacker News Discussion

šŸ“ Discussion Summary (Click to expand)

App Store Search Ads Undermine Core Functionality

Users report that searching for exact app names often returns ads before the actual app, making discovery frustrating and unreliable.

"When users search for my exact app name, apple shoves 2 full screen ads on top of the search results. Sometimes, it's 1 search results sandwiched in between 2 ads which makes the user miss it because they scrolled past the ads." - busymom0
"when someone searches 'Wordle' - that you can't rely on Wordle being the top result is a indictment of the whole ad-supported internet." - mikeyouse

macOS Usability Quirks Challenge Intuitiveness

Debate persists over whether macOS differences are merely unfamiliar or fundamentally non-intuitive, with specific UI elements criticized.

"The 'traffic lights' were pretty confusing to me for a while. Green button made the window grow but not fully maximize... Red appears to quit, but actually doesn't, it merely closes the window." - sholladay
"Itā€™s supposed to grow to the size it needs to fit the content. That button was never a 'maximise' but a 'zoom'." - latexr (explaining actual UI intent)

Monetization Erosion of Premium Experience

Apple's increasing focus on ads and service upsells in paid software conflicts with user expectations of a luxury, ad-free experience.

"Every time I search for, say, 'Signal' and see the first result be a 'promoted' link to 'Whatsapp', my blood boils. F*k any company that shows me ads on the hardware/software that I bought from them." - emacdona
"Apple tradeoffs and design goals are slowly turning more toward additional monetization after you buy the product than focusing on the product per se." - fedeb95

Growing Interest in Platform Alternatives

Disillusionment with both iOS and Android is driving exploration of Linux-based mobile options and platform switching.

"Iā€™ve gone from Apple fanboy to slowly dropping all of my Apple products as it becomes time for new purchases. They are just no longer looking at users like me." - ryandrake
"GrapheneOS with FOSS apps is a premium experience but not where non-technical users will go currently." - Cider9986

šŸš€ Project Ideas

Clean App Store Search

Summary

  • A web/iOS tool that uses Apple's public iTunes Search API to deliver adā€‘free, accurate App Store search results, eliminating the sponsored ads that obscure exact matches.
  • Core value: fast, reliable app discovery for users and indie developers without paying to bypass ads.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience iOS users, indie developers frustrated with App Store ads
Core Feature Search interface that returns only organic results, with sorting, filters, and exactā€‘match highlighting
Tech Stack React/Vue frontend, Node.js/serverless backend calling iTunes Search API (or iOS Shortcut calling the API)
Difficulty Low
Monetization Hobby

Notes

  • Commenters complained: ā€œWhen users search for my exact app name, apple shoves 2 full screen ads on top of the search resultsā€ (busymom0) and ā€œthe exact hit isn't even rated on top!ā€ (boxed).
  • Provides a transparent alternative that could be hosted as a static site or integrated into a Safari extension, giving developers a way to see their true ranking.

macOS UI Tweaks Utility

Summary

  • A preference pane / menu bar app that lets users reconfigure macOS window controls (traffic lights), scroll direction per device, and installation behavior to match Windows/Linux expectations.
  • Core value: reduces friction for newcomers switching from Windows/Linux by making macOS feel more familiar without sacrificing system integrity.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience New macOS users coming from Windows/Linux, developers annoyed by UI quirks
Core Feature Toggle switches: green button = maximize, red button = quit app, independent mouse/trackpad scroll direction, traditional maximize/minimize buttons, clearer appā€‘install UI
Tech Stack Swift (macOS app), using defaults write commands and optional Sparkle for updates
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue-ready: $5 oneā€‘time purchase (or donationā€‘supported)

Notes

  • Users noted: ā€œThe traffic lights were pretty confusingā€¦ā€, ā€œThe scroll direction of a mousewheel cannot be controlled independently from a trackpad.ā€ (sholladay) and ā€œThe classic oneā€¦apps are installed by dragging an app into a folderā€ (sholladay).
  • This utility would directly address those pain points, offering a oneā€‘click way to make macOS behave more like other desktop environments.

Apple Ad & Nag Blocker Profile

Summary

  • A regularly updated DNSā€‘based blocklist (or VPN profile) that blocks domains serving Appleā€™s promotional ads, iCloud upgrade nagging, and App Store search ads, providing an adā€‘free experience without jailbreaking.
  • Core value: stops unā€‘dismissible promotions and settings badges by cutting off the ad servers at the network level.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience iOS/macOS users tired of unā€‘dismissible ads and nag screens in Settings, App Store, Maps, News
Core Feature DNS sinkhole (or VPN) that returns NXDOMAIN for known ad/nag domains (e.g., ads.apple.com, appleā€‘api.ls.apple.com, etc.), updated weekly
Tech Stack Simple hosts file hosted on GitHub; users adopt via AdGuard Home, NextDNS, or router DNS; optional Shortcut to refresh list
Difficulty Low
Monetization Hobby

Notes

  • Users said: ā€œInfuriatingly for iOS users, the only way to disable these promos is to either let them expire ā€” which could take weeksā€¦ or pay for the service being offered.ā€ (article) and ā€œYou get a permanent red badge that you can only dismiss by fully turning off system notifications.ā€ (comment).
  • By blocking the ad servers, the persistent Settings badges and inā€‘app promotions disappear, giving users control without modifying the OS.

iMessage Bridge for Android/Linux

Summary

  • A selfā€‘hosted, Dockerā€‘compatible service that relays iMessage to and from nonā€‘Apple devices using a Mac mini (or jailbroken iPhone) as a gateway, providing
  • Monetization: Hobby

Read Later