IdeaWell

Project ideas from Hacker News discussions.

Ask HN: What did you find out or explore today?

Hacker News Discussion

📝 Discussion Summary (Click to expand)

Here are the 4 most prevalent themes from the Hacker News discussion, along with supporting quotes:

1. Uncovering Unexpected Technical or Historical Details Many participants shared discoveries ranging from obscure web standards and hardware limitations to fascinating historical facts and engineering feats. * "I found out today that the location header of an HTTP redirect can be a tel:+ URI and phone's will actually ask you whether you want to call that number." — blahaj * "Screws weren't standardized until ww2. And even then, they really haven't been." — geuis * "The origins of Port and Starboard on ships. Chosen to be independent of a mariners orientation." — spenjovewkwhalo

2. Practical Coding Challenges and Workarounds A significant portion of the thread focused on the friction of modern software development, specifically dealing with library compatibility, build tools, and hardware interfacing. * "That lodash-es doesn’t ESM lodash/fp, which means there is no straightforward way of using it with Vite after version 5. God help me." — johnfn * "I'm continuously surprised by how difficult it is to plug things together and how non-descriptive cable 'standards' are about the actual capabilities of cables and connectors." — helltone * "Compiles if r is already declared. Creates a new lexical scope that has no access to the outer r. So the outer r doesn't get set. And I get a bug!" — hahahahhaah

3. Deep Dives into Niche Hobbies Users shared specific knowledge gained while exploring specialized interests, from collecting ancient artifacts and brewing fermented foods to managing specific household pets. * "I bought mine from VCoins. They’re pretty inexpensive if you don’t need them certified or anything... I got a few bronze and silver coins from the Middle East and India. They were in good shape at about $10-20 US." — ilinx * "I found out that shiro (white) miso and aka (red) miso are both the same mix of soybeans, salt, and rice malt but fermented for different periods of time." — TimesNewMe * "She usually sleeps at the bottom of her cage, beneath a towel I put down for her... Tonight she has made quite a nest with her towel: It's folded in half... but she has nuzzled her way between the fold, so she has the towel underneath and on top of her. It's super cute." — lanyard-textile

4. Philosophical and Ethical Reflections on Tech and Life Several comments moved beyond specific discoveries to reflect on broader themes like digital autonomy, the human condition, and the ethics of technology. * "I learned about this book / concept: Tools for Conviviality... 'Tools for Conviviality' also introduced Illich's idea of a 'radical monopoly', which describes a technology or service which becomes so exceptionally dominant that even with multiple providers, its users are excluded from society without access to the product." — TheAceOfHearts * "It confounds me why would anyone keep a bird in captivity... Imagine that you have the power to fly and they keep you in a box." — ainiriand * "Give yourself permission to be bad... Felt good to be reminded that if you want to make interesting things, it's ok to flail around. It'll feel foolish and that's completely ok, perhaps necessary." — alance

🚀 Project Ideas

Protocol Handler Sandbox

Summary

  • Solves the security risk of protocols (like tel:) executing unintended actions (e.g., accidental phone calls) by intercepting and analyzing them before execution.
  • Provides a granular, user-friendly UI to audit, edit, and approve protocol triggers, effectively acting as a firewall for URI schemes.
  • Core Value Proposition: Turns opaque system behavior into transparent, controllable interactions, preventing "feature-as-a-bug" surprises.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Power users, privacy advocates, developers, and anyone concerned about application/OS defaults.
Core Feature A system daemon/service that intercepts protocol triggers, presents a configurable decision dialog, and logs execution history.
Tech Stack Rust or Go (for low-level system hooking), GTK/Qt/WinUI for UI, SQLite for logs.
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue-ready: Freemium desktop app (basic features free, advanced scheduling/automation paid).

Notes

  • Why HN commenters would love it: Users expressed surprise at the flexibility of protocol handlers (Aachen: "Did you know that you can assign arbitrary programs (protocol handlers) to arbitrary protocols?"). A tool that visualizes and controls this opaque system layer appeals to the HN ethos of understanding and mastering one's tools.
  • Potential for discussion or practical utility: High. This touches on security, OS internals, and user agency. It could spark debates on default security models versus user convenience.

Confluence of Context

Summary

  • Addresses the frustration of disparate project management tools and the lack of a shared "language" across teams (referenced by ilinx regarding Domain-Driven Design).
  • A tool that uses LLMs to parse Jira tickets, Slack threads, and design docs to automatically generate and maintain a "Ubiquitous Language" glossary and domain model.
  • Core Value Proposition: Reduces software complexity by ensuring architectural alignment and consistent terminology without manual bureaucratic overhead.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Engineering managers, software architects, and mid-to-large sized dev teams.
Core Feature Aggregates text from various sources (Git commits, tickets, chat) and generates a semantic map of project terminology with definitions and relationships.
Tech Stack Python, LLM APIs (OpenAI/Anthropic), Vector DB (Pinecone/Milvus), React frontend.
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue-ready: SaaS subscription per team/month.

Notes

  • Why HN commenters would love it: Directly solves the "maintainability" pain point mentioned by ilinx ("situations like that are why everything gets so complicated"). It leverages AI for practical software engineering rigor, a popular combination on HN.
  • Potential for discussion or practical utility: Very high. Software architecture and DDD are perennial topics. A tool that automates the "boring" parts of DDD would be widely discussed and adopted.

Summary

  • Solves the "cable hell" and connector confusion described by helltone (finding specific USB-C/Modbus cables) and showerst (making custom cables).
  • An AR-enabled mobile app where users scan connectors/cables to identify pinouts, standards, power/data capabilities, and get links to buy the correct adapters or 3D print files for custom cables.
  • Core Value Proposition: Eliminates hours of online searching and guesswork by providing instant, visual identification of obscure hardware interfaces.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Hobbyists, robotics engineers, industrial maintenance workers, and retro-tech enthusiasts.
Core Feature Computer vision model trained on connector types (USB variants, M8, DIN, proprietary) providing real-time overlay info via camera.
Tech Stack Mobile App (Flutter/React Native), Computer Vision (PyTorch/MediaPipe), Cloud API for model inference.
Difficulty High
Monetization Hobby: Free app with affiliate links to hardware stores.

Notes

  • Why HN commenters would love it: helltone explicitly mentioned the difficulty: "I'm continuously surprised by how difficult it is to plug things together and how non-descriptive cable 'standards' are." A practical tool to cut through this ambiguity appeals to the hardware-hacker segment of HN.
  • Potential for discussion or practical utility: High. It addresses a very specific, tangible frustration in the hardware hobbyist and professional space.

ParrotHealth Monitor

Summary

  • Addresses the specific anxiety of caring for egg-laying birds (as shared by lanyard-textile regarding calcium intake and stress monitoring).
  • A specialized health tracking app for bird owners that logs egg-laying cycles, dietary calcium intake, and behavioral changes, offering alerts when veterinary intervention might be needed.
  • Core Value Proposition: Provides peace of mind and data-driven insights for niche pet care, bridging the gap between anecdotal observation and veterinary advice.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Bird owners (specifically parrot/conure owners), avian breeders.
Core Feature Logging of biological events (eggs, molting), diet tracking (calcium sources), and symptom checker based on avian veterinary guidelines.
Tech Stack Mobile App (Swift/Kotlin), Local Storage (SQLite), optionally integrated with wearable bird sensors.
Difficulty Low
Monetization Hobby: Free with optional premium features (detailed analytics/export).

Notes

  • Why HN commenters would love it: The comment thread regarding lanyard-textile's bird showed a high engagement with niche, caring topics. The specific question about calcium ("methinks: Calcium is required to make the egg shell") indicates a knowledge gap that software could fill.
  • Potential for discussion or practical utility: Medium. While niche, it taps into the intersection of "tech for good" and specific pet care communities. It fosters discussion on health monitoring beyond humans.

Ancient Coin Decoder

Summary

  • Solves the barrier to entry for collecting ancient coins mentioned by ilinx (reading Latin inscriptions) and TZubiri (learning Latin's complex declensions).
  • A mobile app using OCR to identify text on ancient coins (Greek, Latin) and provide a translation, historical context, and estimated market value.
  • Core Value Proposition: Makes history accessible and tangible by instantly decoding the "puzzle" of ancient currency, lowering the steep learning curve for beginners.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience History enthusiasts, D&D worldbuilders, amateur numismatists, tourists.
Core Feature Image-to-text OCR specialized for ancient scripts (Uncial, Carolingian minuscule), database of coin types and historical periods.
Tech Stack Mobile App, Custom OCR model (Tesseract fine-tuned), Wikipedia/Numista API for context.
Difficulty High (due to OCR training on worn artifacts)
Monetization Revenue-ready: Freemium (basic translations free), premium for detailed historical reports or valuation guides.

Notes

  • Why HN commenters would love it: ilinx highlighted the fun of "holding a piece of history" but acknowledged the barrier ("learn Latin"). dr_dshiv showed excitement about specific historical artifacts. A tool that democratizes access to this knowledge aligns with the HN love for learning and history.
  • Potential for discussion or practical utility: Medium. It combines computer vision with history, a compelling combination. It could spark threads on the preservation of history through technology.

Read Later