IdeaWell

Project ideas from Hacker News discussions.

CO2 batteries that store grid energy take off globally

Original Article

Hacker News Discussion

📝 Discussion Summary (Click to expand)

1. Efficiency and Cost Competitiveness vs. Lithium-Ion

Discussion heavily compares ~75% round-trip efficiency and claimed 30% lower cost to rapidly falling Li-Ion prices, with skepticism on longevity advantages.
"I'm seeing round trip efficiencies around 75%. That's not terrible." - cogman10
"Li-Ion has become 80% cheaper in the last decade that's not something which will necessarily continue." - AndrewDucker
"Energy Dome expects its LDES solution to be 30 percent cheaper than lithium-ion." - riffraff (citing article)

2. Safety Risks of CO2 Dome Rupture

Major concern is catastrophic CO2 release causing ground-level suffocation, akin to Lake Nyos.
"CO2 is denser than air will pool closer to the ground, and will suffocate anyone in the area." - creativeSlumber
"People will also need to stay back 70 meters or more until the air clears... Good luck running 70m in a CO2 dense atmosphere." - zahlman / SoftTalker

3. Lithium Scarcity and Sodium Alternatives

Debate on lithium limits favors abundant-material options like sodium-ion or LFP batteries.
"Lithium supply is limited. So an alternative based on abundant materials is interesting." - Gys
"Sodium iron phosphate batteries... will be some of the cheapest batteries out there." - cogman10
"We’re matching the performance of [lithium iron phosphate batteries] at roughly 30% lower total cost... - scotty79 (quoting Alsym CEO)

🚀 Project Ideas

Thermal-Sync: Storage & Cooling Co-Optimization

Summary

  • A software modeling and management platform for data center operators that co-locates compressed gas energy storage (like CO2 batteries) with server facilities.
  • It solves the high cost of data center cooling by utilizing the "cold" generated during the decompression/discharge phase of the battery to offset HVAC loads.
  • Core Value Proposition: Increases the effective round-trip efficiency of energy storage by capturing thermal waste, turning a storage expense into a cooling utility.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Data center operators, grid-scale energy planners
Core Feature Predictive thermal/energy load balancing and co-location ROI modeling
Tech Stack Python (scipy/numpy), Digital Twin simulation, IoT sensors (Modbus/BACnet)
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue-ready: SaaS subscription + percentage of energy savings

Notes

  • HN commenters highlighted the synergy: "when you have a cooling use case nearby, you can use that low intensity heat to compensate heat storage losses... compressed gas storage could be useful even if there was zero electric recovery."
  • Directly addresses the concern that mechanical storage has lower round-trip efficiency than Lithium by adding a secondary benefit (cooling).

LDES-Calc: Lifecycle & Unit Economics Auditor

Summary

  • A specialized financial modeling tool for energy engineers to compare Long-Duration Energy Storage (LDES) alternatives (LFP, Sodium-Ion, CO2, Pumped Hydro).
  • It solves the "marketing muck" problem by calculating Levelized Cost of Storage (LCOS) over 20-30 years, factoring in degradation, replacement cycles, and Capex.
  • Core Value Proposition: Objective, data-driven decision support to move past "pitch deck numbers" and "PR releases."

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Energy consultants, utility providers, project investors
Core Feature Sensitivity analysis (e.g., impact of Lithium price drops vs. mechanical wear)
Tech Stack React/Next.js for UI, Rust for heavy simulation logic
Difficulty Low
Monetization Revenue-ready: Per-report fee or enterprise licensing

Notes

  • Commenters were skeptical of "sales flyer" data: "30% cheaper than batteries from when? today? two years ago?"
  • Users demanded better unit analysis: "What we need is a storage technology with a duration of months... cost for a plant like this scales linearly with the storage rate."

Leak-Guard: CO2 Safety & Dispersion Monitoring

Summary

  • An integrated hardware-software safety suite specifically designed for non-pressurized gasbag storage (the "domes" used in CO2 batteries).
  • It provides high-fidelity CO2 pooling alerts and real-time evacuation radius mapping based on topography and local anemometers.
  • Core Value Proposition: Mitigates the "Lake Nyos" suffocation risk, moving beyond the "70-meter rule of thumb" to certified site-specific safety.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Site safety officers, industrial engineering teams
Core Feature Real-time ground-level CO2 concentration mapping and automated sirens
Tech Stack NDIR Gas Sensors, LoRaWAN, WebGL for 3D dispersion visualization
Difficulty High
Monetization Revenue-ready: Hardware sales + safety certification service

Notes

  • Safety was a primary debate point: "CO2 is heavier than air... a dome rip could make air unbreathable, because the CO2 will settle at the bottom."
  • Commenters noted the danger of ground-hugging gas: "That little house about 15m from the bubble needs to be acquired... The topography matters."

Read Later