Court agrees with EFF: Utah's VPN law demands a technical impossibility

Original Article

Hacker News Discussion

📝 Discussion Summary (Click to expand)

Prevalent Themes in the Utah VPN Law Discussion

Technical impossibility of perfect VPN detection
Users overwhelmingly argued that reliably identifying all VPN traffic is fundamentally unachievable due to the ease of creating private/proxied connections.

"No, it's not possible. You can only try to identify known protocols or suspicious patterns of data, timing or entropy." (LoganDark)
"It's impossible to have a full and complete list of VPN exit nodes, for the simple reason that no company publishes the full list..." (gambiting)
Constitutional and jurisdictional overreach
Many contended the law unconstitutionally burdens interstate commerce and exceeds Utah's authority by attempting to regulate global internet traffic.

"The law likely violates the U.S. Constitution’s prohibition on passing laws that significantly burden businesses and people outside Utah’s borders." (gchamonlive)
"regulating non-Utah users on non-Utah sites is not something the Utah law can constitutionally do under the Dormant Commerce Clause." (Ukv)
Ulterior motives (anti-porn/religious agenda)
A significant thread suggested the law's true purpose is to suppress pornography under guises of "child protection," driven by specific ideological groups.

"It lawfare against porn. They don't want these companies to exist. They want it to be impossible to comply with the law to shut them down." (pkilgore)
"The people who would vote for it in Utah do, and that's why Utah is being used as a vehicle by other people to bolster the need to root all computers." (pessimizer)
Ineffectiveness due to easy workarounds
Commenters noted determined users would bypass restrictions via residential proxies, self-hosted solutions, or other trivial methods, rendering the law futile.

"It's hard to find a proxy or VPN that isn't flagged as such. People pay extra for residential proxies." (mahboi)
"Folks would just host their own vpns various places and this would be pointless …." (happyPersonR)

🚀 Project Ideas

VPNGuard API

Summary

Provides a real‑time IP classification service that distinguishes residential, datacenter, and VPN/proxy IPs using continuously updated fingerprinting and heuristic models.
Core value: lets adult sites meet Utah’s VPN‑blocking requirement with far fewer false positives, preserving access for legitimate users.

Details

Key	Value
Target Audience	Adult content platforms, streaming services, any site needing to comply with Utah’s VPN ban
Core Feature	API endpoint returning {ip, is_vpn, confidence, type} with <100ms latency
Tech Stack	Python/FastAPI, Redis cache, periodic scanners of public VPN lists, ML model (TensorFlow Lite) for heuristic scoring
Difficulty	Medium
Monetization	Revenue-ready: usage‑based pricing at $0.001 per IP lookup (free tier 10k lookups/mo)

Notes

HN users complained: “I occasionally get blocked by websites … if I'm on VPN … It's very annoying” (not_a_bot_4sho) and “If you get 100 different users connecting from a single IP, it's probably not someone's home internet connection.” (a4isms)
Offers a practical discussion point: balancing compliance with privacy, and can be extended to offer whitelisting of known residential IPs to reduce overblocking.

AgeShield

Summary

Zero‑knowledge age verification middleware that proves a user is ≥18 without revealing identity or storing personal data.
Core value: enables sites to satisfy Utah’s age‑verification mandate while preserving user privacy and avoiding blanket VPN blocks.

Details

Key	Value
Target Audience	Adult sites, age‑restricted platforms, ISPs looking to avoid overblocking
Core Feature	SDK (JS/WASM) that performs zk‑proof of age using government‑issued ID or credit‑card token, returns signed attestation to the site
Tech Stack	Rust compiled to WASM, libsnark/zokrates for zk‑SNARKs, backend Node.js for token verification
Difficulty	High
Monetization	Revenue-ready: $0.01 per successful verification (volume discounts)

Notes

Commenters noted the law’s impossibility: “It's technically impossible to both implement Utah's law and respect the constitution.” (gchamonlive) and expressed desire for less intrusive checks.
Provides a concrete technical alternative that could spark discussion on privacy‑preserving regulation and be adopted by sites seeking to avoid overblocking.

UtahResiProxy

Summary

Peer‑to‑peer residential proxy network that gives Utah users a legitimate residential IP address (via opt‑in peers outside the state) so their traffic appears non‑VPN to adult sites.
Core value: lets Utah residents access geo‑restricted content without triggering VPN blocks, while preserving the appearance of residential traffic for compliance.

Details

Key	Value
Target Audience	Utah residents who rely on VPNs for work/privacy but want to access age‑restricted sites
Core Feature	App that routes traffic through a distributed pool of residential peers; users earn credits by sharing bandwidth
Tech Stack	Go daemon, libp2p for P2P routing, WebRTC fallback, optional incentivization token (ERC‑20)
Difficulty	Medium
Monetization	Revenue-ready: subscription $5/mo per user or pay‑per‑GB bandwidth; free tier with limited credits

Notes

Users said: “I use VPN most of the time … I occasionally get blocked by websites … if I'm on VPN” (not_a_bot_4sho) and “Folks would just host their own vpns various places and this would be pointless …” (happyPersonR) – showing demand for less detectable alternatives.
Could stimulate discussion on the efficacy of residential proxies vs. VPN detection and the cat‑and‑mouse of regulation.

ComplyKit

Summary

Open‑source toolkit that bundles geofencing, VPN detection integration (via VPNGuard API), age‑verification UI, and compliance reporting for adult sites.
Core value: reduces engineering burden and legal risk by providing a ready‑to‑deploy, configurable solution to meet Utah’s law with minimal overblocking.

Details

Key	Value
Target Audience	Developers and product teams at adult websites, ad networks, and content platforms
Core Feature	Modular Docker‑compose stack: geo‑IP library, VPNGuard API client, AgeShield SDK wrapper, audit logger, and admin dashboard
Tech Stack	Docker, PostgreSQL, React admin UI, Go microservices, Python scripts for updates
Difficulty	Low (for integration)
Monetization	Revenue-ready: paid support, customization, and enterprise licensing tiers

Notes

Commenters highlighted the legal tension: “The law likely violates the U.S. Constitution’s prohibition on passing laws that significantly burden businesses …” (gchamonlive) and noted the need for “reasonable” age verification.
Provides a tangible starting point for discussion on practical compliance and could be adopted widely, reducing the incentive for sites to block all VPN traffic.

Court agrees with EFF: Utah's VPN law demands a technical impossibility

Prevalent Themes in the Utah VPN Law Discussion

🚀 Project Ideas

VPNGuard API

Summary

Details

Notes

AgeShield

Summary

Details

Notes

UtahResiProxy

Summary

Details

Notes

ComplyKit

Summary

Details

Notes

Read Later