IdeaWell

Project ideas from Hacker News discussions.

Fathers’ choices may be packaged and passed down in sperm RNA

Original Article

Hacker News Discussion

📝 Discussion Summary (Click to expand)

1. Skepticism Toward Early-Stage Research and Media Hype

Users widely criticized the article as clickbait with hand-wavy claims, urging caution until more evidence emerges. "It seems to me to all be the handwavy part. I'm happy to wait until the research is considerably further advanced, past the clickbait stage." - jibal
"The literature in this area is a mess, has become highly politicized. I’d give it another 10 or so years before I made any strong statements about these effects in humans." - ch4s3

2. Revival of Lamarckian Ideas via Epigenetics

Debate revived Lamarckism discussions, distinguishing durable epigenetic effects (e.g., stress, diet) from strict Mendelian genetics, with Lysenkoism fears. "Lamarck has entered the chat." - zerofor_conduct
"Is this a revival of Lysenkoism?" - Animats
"Genetics is almost entirely Mendelian, but some of epigenetics is durable and thus Lamarckian." - echelon

3. Limited to Broad Traits, Not Specific Experiences; Offspring Variability

Effects are seen as physiological (e.g., exercise benefits, nicotine tolerance) not specific memories; sibling/twin differences undermine strong inheritance claims. "What can't happen is inter-generational transmission of particular subjective experiences... Only biomolecular-mediated phenotypes... make sense." - harshreality
"My three kids could not be more different and they all have the same mother, grew up in the same house, etc. If 'microRNA' profiles have any influence, I would wager it's very small." - SoftTalker

🚀 Project Ideas

Epigenetics Research Tracker

Summary

  • A web app that lets users follow specific authors, journals, and keywords in epigenetics (e.g., microRNA, paternal inheritance), aggregating feeds from PubMed, Quanta, Cell Metabolism into personalized dashboards with summaries and quality flags (e.g., human vs. mouse studies).
  • Core value: Solves "where can I keep up with this in more mainstream but technical publications" (yieldcrv) and "keeping tabs on authors" (biophysboy) without manual checking.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Scientists, biohackers, prospective parents interested in emerging genetics research
Core Feature Author/journal alerts, AI-summarized papers with skepticism scores (e.g., flags retracted/hand-wavy claims per jibal)
Tech Stack Next.js, PubMed API, RSS parsers, OpenAI for summaries, PostgreSQL
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue-ready: Freemium ($5/mo pro alerts)

Notes

  • HN skeptics like jibal/shevy-java would love quality flags quoting "hand-wavy" or retracted papers.
  • High discussion potential on HN for research tools; practical for tracking "evidence piling up" (whimsicalism).

Sperm Lifecycle Freezer

Summary

  • A service/app partnering with sperm banks for scheduled freezing (e.g., pre-college, post-marriage) with integrated health logging (diet, exercise, stress via wearables) and labels for "best self" snapshots.
  • Core value: Realizes websiteapi's "freeze sperm regularly with labels... snapshot your best self" idea practically, addressing "if you go off the deep end" risks.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Men planning families (20s-40s), biohackers optimizing offspring traits
Core Feature Calendar scheduler for deposits, QR-labeled vials with linked health data/privacy vault
Tech Stack React Native app, Stripe for bank partnerships, Fitbit/Apple Health API, Firebase
Difficulty High
Monetization Revenue-ready: Subscription ($20/mo storage + logging)

Notes

  • Quotes websiteapi/wkat4242 directly; HN would debate ethics/sci-fi viability ("neat premise for a sci fi novella").
  • Utility for "rationalist fathers" (queue) tracking nicotine/exercise effects.

Paternal Epigenome Journal

Summary

  • Mobile app for prospective dads to log daily habits (exercise, nicotine, stress via mood/journal) against latest research, scoring "epigenetic fitness" for sperm quality and visualizing trends.
  • Core value: Turns hand-wavy research (e.g., "paternal exercise confers benefits") into actionable tracking, countering "wait for more research" (jibal) with personal data.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Biohacking dads-to-be, couples optimizing IVF/conception
Core Feature Habit tracker with research-linked scores (e.g., "exercise boost: +20% endurance trait"), export for doctors
Tech Stack Flutter, Supabase, ML model fine-tuned on PubMed epigenetics data
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue-ready: Freemium ($4.99/mo premium insights)

Notes

  • HN anecdotes (bethekidyouwant: "Exercise and take nicotine") fuel shares; addresses harshreality's metabolic profiles.
  • Sparks discussions on twins/siblings variability (SoftTalker/adrianN) with trend visualizations.

Read Later