1️⃣ Distrust of Google’s data‑centric business model
“Oh yeah, a company whose business model is taking everyone’s data and selling it is going to help me secure my data. I guess there’s one born every minute…” — urup2l8
“The consumer offering is massively subsidized by ads and will use your data for ad placement, although they still never sell your data because that would hurt their business.” — sam_lowry_
Google’s core revenue comes from harvesting user data for ads, so many commenters view its “security” promises as little more than marketing spin.
2️⃣ AI‑driven dynamic access control & its risks
“Should this API call on this resource be allowed right now?” — thewebguyd
“What do you think their security model will be trained on? That's right, other people’s data.” — speed_spread
The proposal shifts the permission boundary from static policies to real‑time AI inference, raising concerns that the model itself will be trained on other users’ data and lack deterministic guarantees.
3️⃣ Need for auditability, reversibility, and human safeguards
“Preparing for AI agents means expanding auditability and reversibility in software.” — firasd
“Agree that auditability is important because otherwise you don't know what you don't know.” — mooreds
Commenters stress that without explicit rollback windows, event logs, and human‑in‑the‑loop escalations, AI‑based controls can become opaque and impossible to audit or correct.