IdeaWell

Project ideas from Hacker News discussions.

How Markdown took over the world

Original Article

Hacker News Discussion

📝 Discussion Summary (Click to expand)

1. Superior Alternatives Like Textile and Org-Mode Lost to Momentum

Users lament Markdown's victory over more capable formats like Textile ("superior Sony Betamax to Markdown's VHS" – SoleilAbsolu) and Org-mode ("more featureful syntax" but Emacs-tied – d-us-vb), crediting timing and adoption: "the power of momentum leading to its mass adoption" (ChrisArchitect).

2. Simplicity and Plain-Text Readability as Key Strengths

Markdown excels as human-readable plain text for git, portability, and quick editing: "fundamentally text. No format/vendor lock-in" (Havoc); "nice looking plaintext that can be typeset" (somat); "I can 'render' it in my head very quickly" (tombert).

3. Parsing Ambiguities and Intra-Word Emphasis Issues

Frequent gripes about inconsistencies, e.g., underscores in "mark_up_": "demonstrates an ambiguity in Markdown" (akshayshah); "_ means underline :-)" in Org-mode (BeetleB); "nobody wants _ to mean 'emphasis'" (AlienRobot).

4. "Worse is Better" – Simplicity Over Complex Features

Markdown triumphed via minimalism vs. DocBook/Word: "simpler is not worse, it can... mean better" (atoav); "worse is better" trend like Java/Python (w10-1); unopinionated/limited by design (latexr).

🚀 Project Ideas

Universal Markdown Previewer (UMP)

Summary

  • A lightweight, cross-platform desktop application specifically for viewing (not editing) Markdown files with a "double-click to read" experience.
  • Solves the frustration of users who find Markdown unreadable as raw text but don't want to open a heavy IDE or "Live Preview" editor just to read a document.
  • Unlike browser extensions, it acts as a native file handler for .md, .text, and .markdown files.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Non-technical users and devs who want a "Quick Look" for MD files.
Core Feature Instant high-quality rendering with a "Reader Mode" (ToC, search, print-to-PDF).
Tech Stack Rust (Tauri) or Go (Wails) for low memory footprint; Shiki for syntax highlighting.
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Hobby (Free) OR Revenue-ready: $5-10 one-time "Pro" for custom themes.

Notes

  • HN commenters repeatedly noted the "massive lack of Markdown VIEWERS" and wanting to "double-click on the file and READ it."
  • Addresses the "byte format" and "file extension" confusion mentioned by users who use .text instead of .md.

TableFix: The Markdown Table Optimizer

Summary

  • A CLI tool and VS Code extension that "auto-repads" Markdown tables to be visually perfect in plain text while keeping git diffs clean.
  • Solves the "bounding box" problem where adding a 7-letter name to a table breaks the visual alignment in its raw form.
  • Bridges the gap between "Markdown as source" and "Markdown as a visual medium."

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Technical writers, Open Source maintainers, and Git users.
Core Feature Auto-alignment of table pipes and dashes based on content length.
Tech Stack TypeScript / Node.js.
Difficulty Low
Monetization Hobby

Notes

  • "It can look better if we use fixed width font and add padding... the gripe is what happens when entry 3 is a 7-letter name?"
  • Responds to the desire for "scannable" text that doesn't look like "poo" in its raw state.

Typst-to-Markdown (T2M) Bridge

Summary

  • A specialized conversion and templating engine that allows users to write in simple Markdown but renders using the high-performance Typst engine.
  • Addresses the "complexity vs. power" trade-off; Typst is more capable than Markdown (math, layout, semantic headers) but has a steeper learning curve.
  • Allows "power users" to generate pixel-perfect PDFs and academic-grade documents without leaving the Markdown ecosystem.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Researchers, students, and technical authors.
Core Feature Markdown-to-Typst intermediate compiler with "Template Injection."
Tech Stack Rust, Typst CLI integration.
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Hobby

Notes

  • Commenters noted that "Typst is the love child of latex and markdown" but "too complex for many end users."
  • Solving the "semantic meaning" and "pixel-perfect rendering" limitations found in vanilla Markdown.

Markdown-First Mail Client (or Bridge)

Summary

  • A sleek, privacy-focused email bridge or client that defaults to Markdown input and renders to clean, multi-part HTML/Plain Text for the recipient.
  • Solves the "infuriating" experience of using limited WYSIWYG editors in Gmail/Outlook for people who think in Markdown.
  • Includes a "safe HTML" sanitizer to ensure the output remains standard and readable across all mail clients.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Developers, power-users, and technical managers.
Core Feature Compose emails with code blocks, math, and nested lists using native MD.
Tech Stack Electron or Native (Swift/Kotlin); integration with IMAP/SMTP.
Difficulty High
Monetization Revenue-ready: SaaS subscription ($5/mo) or $40-50/year license.

Notes

  • Users explicitly asked: "Are there any ways to type email in markdown?" and complained about high-priced existing alternatives ($40/yr).
  • Responds to the "keyboard-only formatting" routine that many HN users have adopted.

Read Later