Project ideas from Hacker News discussions.

I now assume that all ads on Apple news are scams

📝 Discussion Summary (Click to expand)

1. Ads are almost universally distrusted
Many commenters treat every ad as a potential scam, arguing that the sheer volume of malicious or misleading ads makes it safer to assume “all ads are scams.”

“I assume all ads are scams.” – frizlab
“All ads are scams.” – deafpolygon

2. Apple News (and Apple’s services) is “enshittified”
Apple’s decision to partner with ad networks like Taboola has turned its premium‑looking news app into a cluttered, low‑quality experience that feels more like a paid ad‑filled feed than a curated news source.

“Apple News is a paid subscription with ads, but the ads are tasteless scam ads.” – FabHK
“Apple News + is the only one of these that has poor quality.” – lotsofpulp

3. The ad‑tech economy rewards scammers
Ad platforms prioritize revenue over safety, allowing scammers to buy cheap inventory and flood the ecosystem with click‑bait, fake landing pages, and dark‑pattern ads.

“The financial optimum for any ad company is to accommodate scams.” – dev_l1x_be
“The ad industry is flooded with scams… the payment processors are making money on their obscene 1%+ processing markups.” – tart‑lemonade

4. Users rely on blockers and filtering to survive
Because of the prevalence of malicious ads, many users adopt aggressive ad‑blocking, privacy‑preserving tools, or simply avoid platforms that don’t allow blocking.

“I block all ads. The bits that cross the threshold onto your networks and devices are yours to display or not.” – Terretta
“I use PiHole, uBlock Origin, and Safari’s built‑in blocker to keep the web clean.” – warmwash

5. Apple’s shift from hardware excellence to service‑driven revenue is criticized
Long‑time Apple fans lament that the company’s focus on services (Apple News, Apple TV+, Fitness+, etc.) has eroded the quality and user experience that once defined the brand.

“Apple’s services strategy has changed this perception. I question Apple’s competitive advantage when they shift to a Google‑like business model.” – al_borland
“Steve Jobs was all about the customer experience… Tim Cook lost the way, spending too much time on the stock.” – jorvi

These five themes capture the bulk of the discussion: distrust of advertising, Apple’s ad‑filled services, the economics that enable scams, user‑side defenses, and the broader critique of Apple’s strategic pivot.


🚀 Project Ideas

Apple News Ad Blocker

Summary

  • A local VPN service that intercepts Apple News traffic and removes ad elements in real time, giving users a clean reading experience.
  • Core value: eliminates intrusive, scammy ads that Apple News currently serves, restoring the premium feel of the app.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience iOS users who subscribe to Apple News+ but are frustrated by ads
Core Feature Real‑time ad removal via a local VPN proxy that rewrites Apple News HTML
Tech Stack Swift (iOS), Network Extension API, Rust for performance, Docker for serverless edge functions
Difficulty High
Monetization Revenue‑ready: $4.99/month subscription

Notes

  • HN users complain that “Apple News ads are a cancer” and that “Apple News+ still shows ads.”
  • A VPN‑based blocker works on all iOS versions, including those that don’t allow jailbreak tweaks.
  • The product can be marketed as “the only way to keep Apple News ad‑free without jailbreaking.”

Verified Ad Marketplace

Summary

  • A platform where advertisers pay a fee to have their ads vetted by a community of users before being served on any network.
  • Core value: reduces scam ads and restores trust in online advertising.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Advertisers, ad networks, and publishers
Core Feature Community‑reviewed ad approval workflow + automated fraud detection
Tech Stack Node.js, PostgreSQL, ML models (TensorFlow), React admin UI
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue‑ready: $0.50 per approved ad + 10% commission on ad spend

Notes

  • HN commenters note that “scam ads are everywhere” and that “ad networks don’t vet properly.”
  • By turning vetting into a paid service, the marketplace creates a financial incentive for quality.
  • The community review layer gives users a sense of ownership and transparency.

Ad‑Free News Aggregator

Summary

  • A subscription service that aggregates news from multiple publishers, removes all ads, and offers a clean reading interface.
  • Core value: provides a premium, ad‑free alternative to Apple News+ and other paid news apps.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience News readers who pay for Apple News+ but want an ad‑free experience
Core Feature RSS/Atom feed ingestion + publisher API integration + ad‑free rendering
Tech Stack Go (backend), GraphQL, Flutter (mobile), Docker
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue‑ready: $9.99/month or $99/year

Notes

  • HN users lament that “Apple News+ still shows ads” and that “Apple News content is low quality.”
  • The aggregator can negotiate content deals with publishers, offering them a new revenue stream.
  • The clean UI and ad‑free promise will resonate with the “trusted community” mindset of HN.

Ad Transparency Dashboard

Summary

  • A browser extension that displays the source, advertiser, and targeting data for every ad on a page, and lets users block or whitelist them.
  • Core value: empowers users to see who is behind an ad and decide whether to trust it.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Web users who use ad blockers but want more context
Core Feature Real‑time ad metadata extraction + blocklist/whitelist UI
Tech Stack JavaScript, WebExtension APIs, Chrome/Firefox/Edge support
Difficulty Low
Monetization Hobby (free)

Notes

  • HN commenters say “I can’t tell if an ad is legit” and “I want to block scam ads.”
  • The dashboard turns opaque ad traffic into transparent, actionable information.
  • It can be bundled with existing ad blockers for a richer experience.

AI Scam Ad Detector API

Summary

  • A cloud API that scans ad creatives and landing pages in real time, flagging potential scams or malicious content.
  • Core value: gives ad networks, publishers, and users a tool to filter out harmful ads before they appear.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Ad networks, publishers, security teams
Core Feature ML‑based image, text, and URL analysis + risk scoring
Tech Stack Python, PyTorch, Kubernetes, REST API
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue‑ready: $0.02 per scan + tiered subscription

Notes

  • HN users note that “ads are full of scams” and that “ad fraud is rampant.”
  • The API can be integrated into existing ad platforms or used by security researchers.
  • By providing a quantifiable risk score, it helps users decide whether to block an ad.

Customizable News Feed App

Summary

  • A mobile app that lets users curate their own news feed, block unwanted publishers, and includes a built‑in ad blocker for all apps via a local VPN.
  • Core value: gives users full control over what they read and eliminates unwanted ads across the device.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience iOS/Android users who want a personalized, ad‑free news experience
Core Feature Publisher whitelist/blacklist, local VPN ad blocker, content aggregation
Tech Stack Kotlin/Swift, Rust for VPN, SQLite, MVVM architecture
Difficulty High
Monetization Revenue‑ready: $3.99/month for premium features (advanced filtering, cloud sync)

Notes

  • HN commenters complain that “Apple News ads are intrusive” and that “ad blockers don’t work on mobile.”
  • The app’s VPN layer can filter ads from any source, not just Apple News.
  • The customizable feed satisfies the HN desire for a “trusted community” curated experience.

Read Later