IdeaWell

Project ideas from Hacker News discussions.

Inside CECOT – 60 Minutes [video]

Original Article

Hacker News Discussion

📝 Discussion Summary (Click to expand)

1. Preservation of Suppressed Video

Users rally to archive and torrent the 60 Minutes segment, fearing DMCA takedowns.
"scratchyone: I have a feeling this will get DMCA-ed off of Internet Archive... Here's the infohash..."
"ProllyInfamous: Hey there seed buddy... I'm about to become the fourth web seed. We're not going anywhere."

2. Censorship by CBS Leadership (Bari Weiss)

Outrage at Weiss suppressing the report to appease Trump admin/Ellison; she's called unqualified propagandist.
"kg: this report was suppressed by CBS News' new leadership, most likely to appease the US government."
"aksnsbba: She is more or less an Israeli propaganda agent... hired at CBS because... Zionist Larry Ellison... needed a reliable Zionist editor in chief."

3. HN Moderation Bias and Flagging

Complaints of posts flagged off front page, 404media shadowbans, mod title edits favoring VCs/Trump.
"mrjay42: Why all those articles on HN are 'flagged'? And by WHOM? Do Trumpist minions have their ways on HN?"
"tastyface: 404media is shadowbanned from HN... The mods should really revisit this policy."

🚀 Project Ideas

P2P News Integrity Network

Summary

  • A decentralized, peer-to-peer system for distributing and verifying suppressed journalistic content (like the 60 Minutes segment) against takedowns.
  • It ensures content integrity and high availability using BitTorrent technology combined with cryptographic hashing and a web-of-trust verification layer.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Journalists, archivists, activists, and readers concerned about media censorship and content longevity.
Core Feature Automated monitoring of news outlets for "missing" high-interest stories, instantly generating and seeding torrents while broadcasting verification hashes to a decentralized ledger.
Tech Stack WebTorrent (WebRTC + BitTorrent), IPFS (for persistence), React (Frontend), Node.js (Backend), Ethereum/ENS (for hash anchoring).
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Hobby (Open Source)

Notes

  • Users explicitly discussed the need for torrents and seed buddies (e.g., "We're not going anywhere. —Hydra") to keep the file alive.
  • This project leverages the "Streisand Effect" by automating the distribution of suppressed content, ensuring it remains accessible despite corporate takedowns.

Journalist Ethics & Censorship Tracker

Summary

  • A browser extension and web platform that aggregates media ownership changes, editorial conflicts of interest, and reported instances of story suppression.
  • It contextualizes news articles by overlaying data on the financial and political ties of the editors and owners involved.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Media literacy enthusiasts, researchers, and HN users skeptical of corporate media narratives.
Core Feature Aggregates data on media ownership (e.g., Ellison's acquisition of CBS) and flags conflicts of interest when specific stories are killed or modified.
Tech Stack Browser Extension (Manifest V3), Python (Scraping/API), PostgreSQL (Database), Tailwind CSS (UI).
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Hobby (Open Source)

Notes

  • The discussion centers heavily on the context of the story: "Paramount’s hostile takeover," "Ellison... needs a reliable Zionist editor," and Bari Weiss's hiring.
  • Users are explicitly looking for context on why stories are spiked, citing corruption and political appeasement.

Distributed Archival Daemon

Summary

  • A lightweight, "set-and-forget" headless utility for Raspberry Pi/NAS devices that automatically mirrors specific URLs or torrents to the Internet Archive and personal storage.
  • It acts as a "web seed" for critical files without requiring technical expertise.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Data hoarders, "seed buddies," and users with always-on home servers (NAS/SBCs).
Core Feature Monitors a user-curated list of URLs (e.g., news links). If a link 404s or is flagged, it automatically uploads the content to an archival service and seeds it via BitTorrent.
Tech Stack Docker, Python (Requests/BeautifulSoup), Transmission CLI (for BitTorrent), Internet Archive API.
Difficulty Low
Monetization Hobby (Open Source)

Notes

  • Users asked, "What's the best torrent client nowadays?" (qbittorrent, Transmission) and discussed headless setups for Raspberry Pi.
  • The specific request for "The Transmission daemon can be installed headless with negligible system load" validates the need for a lightweight archival tool.

NewsGate: Verified Commentary Platform

Summary

  • A discussion platform that bridges the gap between news reporting and reader analysis by requiring "verified journalist" tags for sourcing and open "community notes" for context.
  • It aims to solve the issue of "flagged" or suppressed stories by allowing community discussion to persist independently of the source article's availability.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Users frustrated with HN flagging/ moderation, and those seeking unfiltered discussion on controversial topics.
Core Feature Threaded discussions where top-level comments must link to archival sources (like archive.ph) to prevent link rot. Includes a reputation system for "context adders."
Tech Stack Next.js, Supabase (Auth/DB), Tailwind CSS.
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Hobby (Open Source)

Notes

  • The thread is full of complaints about HN flags and moderation ("marked as a duplicate," "flagged completely off the first 5 pages").
  • Users are actively seeking alternative discussion forums ("Where are the independent and non-VC fueled discussion forums when you need them?").

VPN Port Forwarding & Seeding Optimizer

Summary

  • A tool to configure VPN clients specifically for optimal torrent seeding, solving the issue where popular privacy VPNs (like Mullvad) lack port forwarding, causing low seed counts.
  • It automates the setup of split tunneling and port forwarding to ensure users can contribute effectively to the P2P swarm.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience BitTorrent users who want to seed content for causes but are limited by VPN restrictions.
Core Feature A GUI wrapper that configures WireGuard/OpenVPN profiles to route only torrent traffic through the VPN while managing port forwarding dynamically.
Tech Stack Electron (GUI), Go (Network layer), WireGuard/OpenVPN.
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue-ready (Freemium model: Basic config free, auto-updating port lists for premium).

Notes

  • Users explicitly debated VPNs: "Mullvad doesn't do port forwarding; you won't be able to seed effectively" vs. "Proton VPN has port forwarding."
  • This addresses a technical pain point mentioned by utrack regarding seeding efficacy.

Unified Media Mirror & Verification Service

Summary

  • A service that accepts media tips (like the leaked 60 Minutes segment), automatically generates checksums, mirrors to multiple decentralized storage providers (IPFS, Storj, S3), and creates a verifiable "proof of existence" certificate.
  • It solves the problem of single points of failure (like Archive.org getting a DMCA takedown).

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Whistleblowers, investigative journalists, and archivists.
Core Feature One-click upload that distributes a file across a mesh network (BitTorrent + IPFS) and mints a timestamped NFT or hash on a public blockchain to prove the file existed prior to any takedown attempt.
Tech Stack IPFS Cluster, Filecoin (for cold storage), Ethereum/Solana (for anchoring), React.
Difficulty High
Monetization Revenue-ready (Pay-per-upload or subscription for enterprise archiving).

Notes

  • scratchyone provided an infohash to future-proof the file against DMCA removals: 8105370ed7dba50dc7ec659fd67550569b4dd8a0.
  • The discussion highlights the fragility of centralized archives ("DMCA-ed off of Internet Archive") and the need for distributed verification.

Read Later