IdeaWell

Project ideas from Hacker News discussions.

LibreOffice breaks download records after declaring it has no AI features

Original Article

Hacker News Discussion

📝 Discussion Summary (Click to expand)

Four dominant themes in the Hacker News discussion

  1. Codex/Claude bundling LibreOffice inflates download numbers
  2. “Yeah, an AI tool: The ChatGPT/Codex app bundles a full copy of LibreOffice” – andai
  3. “Could also be due to the fact that every codex install includes a copy of libreoffice” – jgbuddy

  4. “People who have never known about Libre Office are now downloading and using Libre Office (often without realizing it).” – vayup

  5. “Record‑breaking” weekly downloads are meaningless because numbers have been rising steadily

  6. “The number of weekly downloads has simply been increasing over time, due to growing popularity. Calling each new high 'record-breaking' is a bit meaningless.” – smokel
  7. “Calling each new high 'record-breaking' is a bit meaningless.” – tzs (repeated)

  8. “If every 'weekly download count after a new release' … is consistently being broken on each new release due to generally increasing popularity, then it doesn’t make sense to imply causality …” – progval

  9. Lack of built‑in AI is seen as a feature (anti‑AI sentiment) vs. desire for optional AI

  10. “Yes, no (built-in) AI is now a feature” – ChrisArchitect (link)
  11. “You’re wrong. … AI is deeply unpopular with the general public and products that don’t include it are rapidly gaining in popularity. People are tired of AI being shoved down their throats without consent.” – r053bud

  12. “I'm not anti‑AI, but I don't want it to be shoved down my throat in any and every app I have.” – bayindirh

  13. Disagreement over how downloads are counted and what the stats really show

  14. “Switching to the monthly view, the downloads are actually mostly flat going back to 2019.” – Aurornis
  15. “I'd hardly consider fluctuations between 2.2 million and 3.3 million downloads 'flat'.” – vanderZwan
  16. “Looking at the stats in day view … the downloads for their release week were actually around 1.259 million … The Document Foundation is based in Germany so I kind of expected they would use ISO weeks.” – tzs (detailed week‑numbering critique)

🚀 Project Ideas

LibreOffice AI Consent Extension

Summary

  • Provides an opt‑in AI plugin framework for LibreOffice that lets users enable/disable AI features locally, ensuring no telemetry or data leaves the machine without consent.
  • Core value: gives users control over AI integration, addressing frustration with forced AI while still allowing useful AI assistance when desired.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience LibreOffice users who want AI capabilities but insist on privacy and opt‑in control
Core Feature Extension that adds AI toolbar/menu items only after user activation, integrates with local LLMs (Ollama, Llama.cpp) and optional cloud providers, with granular settings to disable telemetry
Tech Stack C++/UNO for LibreOffice extension, Python bridge for LLM inference, configurable via JSON settings
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Hobby

Notes

  • HN users expressed desire for AI to be optional and not shoved in (e.g., “I want my AI app to be able to read and write word docs, but when i decide to open up libreoffice i'm doing that because i want to write something myself”).
  • Could spark discussion on balancing AI utility with user autonomy and become a reference implementation for privacy‑first AI in open‑office suites.

LibreOffice Headless Agent Service (LHAS)

Summary

  • A lightweight, containerized service that exposes LibreOffice’s document conversion, generation, and scripting capabilities via a simple REST/gRPC API for LLM agents like Codex or Claude.
  • Core value: enables AI agents to programmatically use LibreOffice without bundling the full desktop app, reducing download bloat and giving operators control over data handling.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Developers building LLM‑powered document workflows, AI agent platforms, and enterprises needing reliable headless office processing
Core Feature API endpoints for converting DOCX↔ODT↔PDF, running macros, executing UNO scripts, with authentication, sandboxing, and optional audit logs
Tech Stack LibreOffice headless (soffice) wrapped in a Docker container, using FastAPI or gRPC, with Prometheus metrics
Difficulty Medium‑High
Monetization Hobby

Notes

  • Commenters noted that Codex bundles LibreOffice for doc editing and that a headless CLI is already used by agents; a dedicated service would simplify integration and reduce duplicate downloads.
  • Could become a useful building block for AI‑agent tooling, sparking discussion on standardizing headless office APIs for LLM workflows.

PrivacyFirst Remote Assist

Summary

  • An open‑source, cross‑platform remote assistance tool designed for non‑technical users (e.g., elderly family members) that replaces the removed Windows Remote Assistance with a simple, end‑to‑end encrypted connection.
  • Core value: provides easy, privacy‑respecting remote help without AI bloat or telemetry, letting helpers view/control a remote screen with minimal setup.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Family tech supporters, small businesses, and anyone needing simple remote help for less‑tech‑savvy users
Core Feature One‑click invitation (via QR code or short link), TLS‑encrypted WebRTC‑based screen sharing, optional chat, no account required, works on Windows, macOS, Linux
Tech Stack WebRTC (using libwebrtc), signaling via simple WebSocket (Node.js or Go), native wrappers for system tray/UI (Electron or Tauri)
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Hobby

Notes

  • HN commenters lamented the removal of Remote Assistance from Windows and the difficulty of helping relatives (e.g., “the jagoffs at Microsoft REMOVED Remote Assistance… I use Google remote desktop…”).
  • A privacy‑focused, open alternative would be welcomed and could spark discussion on balancing ease of use with security in remote support tools.

LibreOffice Pure Build

Summary

  • A hardened distribution of LibreOffice that strips out any AI‑related code, telemetry, and optional online services, providing a pure, AI‑free office suite with a simple global toggle to disable any remaining optional features.
  • Core value: satisfies users who want an office suite that “just works” without hidden AI, data collection, or unwanted features, while retaining full compatibility.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Privacy‑conscious individuals, enterprises, and institutions that require audit‑able, AI‑free software
Core Feature Custom LibreOffice build with AI modules removed, telemetry disabled, and a UI‑wide “AI‑Free Mode” switch that grays out any AI‑related entries
Tech Stack LibreOffice source build system, patches to remove AI extensions, CI/CD pipeline for producing Windows/macOS/Linux installers
Difficulty Low‑Medium
Monetization Hobby

Notes

  • Users repeatedly said “No AI features is the first feature in years that shipped on time and worked on the first try” and expressed desire for software that “just works” without AI being shoved in.
  • Providing a certified AI‑free build would give those users a concrete option and could stimulate discussion on what constitutes “AI‑free” in open‑source software.

Read Later