IdeaWell

Project ideas from Hacker News discussions.

Mozilla appoints new CEO Anthony Enzor-Demeo

Original Article

Hacker News Discussion

📝 Discussion Summary (Click to expand)

1. Criticism of Non-Technical Leadership

Users decry the new MBA/Product Manager CEO, preferring engineers, and revisit Brendan Eich's 2014 ouster over his anti-gay marriage donation as a symbol of poor decisions.
"Why can't we get a software engineer or computer scientist?" (ecshafer)
"What Mozilla needs is a change in leadership direction, not another MBA." (lawn)
"Mozilla had, and has, a lot of LGBT staff. How could you expect those staff to work under and trust a CEO opposed to their very existence..." (lalaland1125)

2. Opposition to AI Pivot Undermining "Trust"

Mozilla's "trusted AI browser" strategy is mocked as contradictory to privacy/adblocking strengths, with users fearing bloat and data risks.
"Firefox's only unique selling point is 'We aren't a massive data vampire.' If they clutter the browser with AI... they dilute their only true differentiator." (Fiveplus)
"AI should always be a choice — something people can easily turn off. [Then:] Firefox will... evolve into a modern AI browser." (summermusic, quoting strategy)
"Nobody wants AI in firefox." (4gotunameagain)

3. Firefox's Decline and Uncertain Future

Blame Google's funding dominance, mobile failures, and mismanagement for <5% share; praise adblocking/extensions but urge focus on core browser over side projects.
"I will eat my hat if Google had nothing to do with the demise of Mozilla..." (4gotunameagain)
"Mozilla’s challenges are foundational, Eich as CEO wouldn’t have made a dramatic difference..." (afavour)
"Focus 100% on Firefox Desktop & Mobile - just a fast solid minimalist browser (no AI, no BS) - builtin, first-class, adblocker..." (miki_oomiri)

🚀 Project Ideas

GeckoPatron

Summary

  • A transparent crowdfunding platform dedicated to funding independent Gecko engine and Firefox fork maintainers, allowing donors to vote on bounties for features like adblocking enhancements, performance optimizations, or AI removal.
  • Core value: Bypasses Mozilla's mismanagement, directly sustains open engine diversity without Google dependency.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Privacy-focused users, Linux devs, Firefox fork enthusiasts (e.g., Librewolf users)
Core Feature Bounty system with donor-voted priorities, automated payouts via crypto/smart contracts, public dashboards tracking funded commits
Tech Stack Next.js frontend, Ethereum/Solana for bounties, GitHub API integration for progress tracking
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue-ready: 5% platform fee on bounties

Notes

  • Addresses "Mozilla will be fine without all the non-sense people, just put engineers in charge" and funding woes like "Donations only get you so far."
  • High potential for HN discussion on browser sustainability; practical for rallying devs around forks.

ForkForge

Summary

  • Automated toolkit for creating and maintaining customized Firefox forks, applying patches for privacy hardening, AI removal, Manifest V2 support, and custom configs with one-click builds and updates.
  • Core value: Empowers users/communities to fork without Mozilla's "AI first" direction, sustaining viable alternatives like Librewolf at scale.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Power users, fork maintainers (Librewolf, Floorp), Linux distro packagers
Core Feature Web UI for selecting patches (e.g., arkenfox user.js, uBO tweaks), CI/CD builds for desktop/mobile, auto-merge upstream Gecko changes
Tech Stack Rust CLI tool, GitHub Actions/Docker for builds, Nix for reproducible environments
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Hobby

Notes

  • Solves "fork Firefox away from Mozilla" and "Librewolf but with dark mode"; quotes like "Would any of these soft forks survive without Mozilla?" highlight need.
  • Utility for tab hoarders/devs wanting "no AI, builtin adblocker"; sparks fork-sharing discussions.

ShieldFox Mobile

Summary

  • Gecko-based Android browser with native, full uBlock Origin-equivalent ad/tracker blocking, vertical tabs, and optimized multi-tab memory management, no telemetry or AI.
  • Core value: Delivers desktop-grade privacy/adblocking on mobile where Chromium dominates, countering "Firefox Android... slower than Chrome" complaints.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Android privacy users tired of Chrome ads, tab hoarders on mobile
Core Feature Embedded filter lists engine (Manifest V2-like), hardware-accelerated tab unloading, Kagi/DDG integration option
Tech Stack GeckoView (Firefox for Android base), Rust for blocker core, Kotlin for UI
Difficulty High
Monetization Revenue-ready: Donations + premium themes ($1.99)

Notes

  • Targets "Firefox on Android with uBO still feels... slower" and "extension support on mobile is worth more"; users praise "uBlock Origin works just like on desktop."
  • Viable for "partner with Kagi"; HN would love mobile Gecko revival for engine diversity.

Read Later