Project ideas from Hacker News discussions.

New York City to to ban deceptive subscription practices

📝 Discussion Summary (Click to expand)

1. NYT’s notorious “hard‑to‑cancel” subscription

The New York Times is repeatedly called out for making it unusually difficult to cancel a subscription.

"NYT is one of the worst and most famous offenders of making it hard to cancel your subscription." — cm2012

2. City‑level “junk‑fee” and all‑in‑price rules

NYC officials are pushing a rule that forces sellers to display total prices—including any mandatory fees—up front, targeting hidden subscription and service charges.

"The city is also targeting so‑called ‘junk fees’ that raise the final price of everything from apartments to sporting events, with a proposed rule that requires sellers to ‘advertise the total price for any good or service, including all mandatory additional charges and fees, up front’." — sxp

3. Hidden surcharges & the tip‑culture debate in restaurants

Many eateries add “living‑wage” or “service” surcharges that are hidden until the bill arrives, fueling frustration over deceptive fee‑shifting.

"3.5% Living Wage Surcharge added to each bill which allows us to provide the service you have always enjoyed!" — buzer
"restaurant owners trying to get their customers involved in their political whining." — sxp

4. Enforceability and jurisdictional limits of NYC’s rulemaking

The ability of a single city to set statewide‑impact standards raises questions about legal reach and practical enforcement.

"Generally when a seller in state X in the US sells to a buyer in a different state Y the consumer protection laws of state Y apply." — tzs


These four themes capture the core concerns of the discussion: the NYT’s subscription hurdles, the drive for transparent all‑in pricing, restaurant surcharge practices, and the legal enforceability of city‑level regulations.


🚀 Project Ideas

Click-to-Cancel Auditor

Summary

  • Scans websites for missing or misleading “cancel” flows and flags compliance gaps.
  • Generates a compliance score and remediation checklist for businesses.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience SaaS product managers, subscription-based startups, legal/compliance teams
Core Feature Automated audit of signup & cancellation pages; real‑time alerts when customer journeys deviate from “as easy to cancel as subscribe” standards
Tech Stack Python + Playwright, React front‑end, PostgreSQL for storing audit reports
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue-ready: SaaS subscription, $49/mo per 10k scans

Notes

  • HN commenters repeatedly cite the NYT’s “hard to cancel” experience; this tool lets companies pre‑empt regulatory backlash.
  • Could integrate with CI pipelines to block releases that fail the audit, creating a strong market differentiator.

Unified Subscription Manager

Summary

  • Central hub for users to store all recurring subscriptions and cancel any with a single click, automatically routing requests to the appropriate service.
  • Tracks renewal dates, fees, and junk‑fee disclosures.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience End‑users, personal finance apps, consumer advocacy groups
Core Feature One‑click cancellation across multiple services; auto‑generated email templates; legal‑ready cancellation proof
Tech Stack Node.js/Express API, GraphQL, Stripe webhooks, React Native mobile front‑end
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Hobby

Notes

  • Users lament the NYT’s “call‑center” hurdle; this removes the friction while providing audit trails for potential enforcement actions.
  • Potential partnership with consumer‑rights NGOs to amplify impact.

Junk‑Fee Detector Browser Extension

Summary

  • Automatically detects and highlights “junk fees” (service charges, living‑wage surcharges, etc.) in online menus and checkout flows.
  • Provides a one‑click “report” button to send findings to city consumer‑protection APIs.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Consumers, consumer‑rights watchdogs, city agencies
Core Feature Real‑time parsing of website price structures; popup alerts; crowdsourced mapping of fee‑type violations
Tech Stack JavaScript (content scripts), Chrome/Firefox extension APIs, Flask backend for reporting portal
Difficulty Low
Monetization Hobby

Notes

  • Directly addresses HN threads about restaurants hiding “living‑wage” surcharges; empowers users to call out deceptive pricing.
  • Could be leveraged by NYC’s new rule enforcement team for crowdsourced compliance monitoring.

All‑In‑Pricing API for E‑Commerce

Summary

  • API service that forces merchants to display the total price (including taxes, fees, surcharges) before the user adds to cart, ensuring “junk‑fee” transparency.
  • Returns a compliance badge and audit log when a site meets the standard.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience E‑commerce platforms, payment gateways, regulatory tech firms
Core Feature Price aggregation middleware; mandatory fee disclosure schema; automated tests for hidden fees
Tech Stack Go micro‑services, Docker, OpenAPI spec, PostgreSQL for audit logs
Difficulty High
Monetization Revenue-ready: Pay‑per‑request, $0.001 per price verification

Notes

  • Echoes California’s anti‑drip pricing law discussions; provides enforceable technical compliance that cities could mandate for any merchant operating in their jurisdiction.
  • Aligns with HN demand for “advertise the total price up front” legislation.

Read Later