IdeaWell

Project ideas from Hacker News discussions.

NTP at NIST Boulder Has Lost Power

Original Article

Hacker News Discussion

📝 Discussion Summary (Click to expand)

1. Minimal Impact Due to Redundancies

NIST Boulder outage poses little risk, as alternatives like GPS, other atomic clocks, and NTP pools (e.g., pool.ntp.org, Google/AWS) ensure stability.
"Google has their own fleet of atomic clocks and time servers. So does AWS. So does Microsoft. So does Ubuntu. They're not going to drift enough for months to cause trouble." (Animats)
"Nothing bad will happen, except to those who have deliberately made these specific Stratum 0 clocks their only reference time." (lambdaone)

2. Humor on Time Travel and Clocks

Many quip about time travel dangers, brakes, and being "stuck travelling into the future."
"Time travel is extremely dangerous right now. I highly recommend deferring time travel plans except for extreme temporal emergencies." (autarch)
"Uhh, here's the problem, I'm sort of stuck travelling into the future at a more or less constant rate." (verzali)

3. Clock Drift is Manageable

Local clocks drift seconds per week/month but holdover suffices short-term; hyperscalers/scientific setups use superior oscillators.
"Several seconds per week is normal. Oscillator accuracy is roughly on the order of 10 PPM, which would correspond to 6 seconds per week." (layer8)
"Most laptops, smartphones, tablets, etc. would be accurate enough for days before drift affected things." (sdrmill)

🚀 Project Ideas

NTP Status Monitor

Summary

  • A web dashboard and CLI tool that aggregates real-time status of NIST and other stratum 0/1 NTP servers, including uptime, latency, offset, and reachability from multiple global vantage points.
  • Core value: Instant visibility into outages like the Boulder closure, preventing surprises for sysadmins relying on specific servers.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Sysadmins, DevOps engineers, and researchers monitoring NTP dependencies
Core Feature Live polling of servers via NTP queries, historical graphs, customizable alerts (email/Slack) for downtime
Tech Stack Go (for CLI/agent), React/Vue for dashboard, InfluxDB/Grafana for metrics, Docker for deployment
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue-ready: Freemium (basic free, pro alerts $10/mo)

Notes

  • Addresses "NIST's main web site says they put status info on various social media accounts, but there's no announcement about this" and frequent checks to tf.nist.gov/tf-cgi/servers.cgi.
  • HN would love the practical utility for debugging drifts ("Clocks do drift. Seconds a week is definitely possible") and sparking discussions on global redundancy.

NTP Config Auditor

Summary

  • An open-source tool that audits NTP/Chrony configurations, detects single-source dependencies (e.g., hardcoded NIST), simulates failovers, and auto-generates resilient configs using pools like pool.ntp.org.
  • Core value: Prevents outages from poor setups, enforces best practices like ≥4 diverse sources.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Sysadmins and infrastructure teams with legacy NTP setups
Core Feature Parse configs, run test syncs, score resilience (e.g., "2/10: only NIST"), output fixed configs with validation
Tech Stack Python (ntplib, configparser), Ansible for deployment, GitHub Actions for CI scans
Difficulty Low
Monetization Hobby

Notes

  • Fixes "Sysadmins would need to update hardcoded NTP configurations" and "if you have 3 or more sources that would be caught; NTP protocol was designed for that."
  • High discussion potential on HN for sharing war stories ("I set up at least 5 domain dns servers pointing at nist ntp") and utility in audits.

Local GPS-NTP Stratum 1 Kit

Summary

  • DIY software kit for Raspberry Pi + cheap GPS module (e.g., u-blox) to create a personal GPS-disciplined NTP server with atomic holdover simulation and drift monitoring.
  • Core value: Independence from public NTP during outages, accurate local time for critical apps.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Hobbyists, small teams, and paranoid engineers wanting self-hosted stratum 1
Core Feature Auto-configure Chrony/ntpd with GPS PPS, web UI for drift graphs/alerts, export to local network
Tech Stack Raspberry Pi OS, Chrony, gpsd, Node.js for UI, InfluxDB for logging
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue-ready: $29 kit (pre-flashed SD + docs)

Notes

  • Responds to "if your application is so critical... you aren't generating your own via gps, you are incompetent" and interest in vendors like Meinberg/Accubeat.
  • HN commenters would rave about hands-on atomic/GPS builds ("I have one such GPS-backed NTP server on the shelf") and resilience demos.

Read Later