IdeaWell

Project ideas from Hacker News discussions.

Obscura: The first VPN that can't log your activity

Original Article

Hacker News Discussion

📝 Discussion Summary (Click to expand)

Theme 1 – Questionable value over Mullvad
Many commenters see Obscura as offering little that Mullvad doesn’t already provide, calling it a unnecessary middle‑man.

“I don't understand the point of this. Many (if not all) of the benefits on the landing page are available in Mullvad too… Why should I choose this over Mullvad?” – maxloh
“Basically a middle‑man for a Mullvad VPN, where if Mullvad decides to pull out… you lose your connection.” – iAMkenough

Theme 2 – Privacy and trust concerns
Users worry about data collection, single points of failure, and the general skepticism toward VPN providers.

“How does this prove Obscura and Mullvad can't just both gather tracking data and then just combine it on demand?” – hehdtyjjoj
“Obscura itself is also a point of failure.” – dgellow
“I am very skeptical of most VPN companies…” – john_strinlai

Theme 3 – Design and branding reactions
The site’s visual style and marketing tone draw both praise and criticism for being incoherent or overly gimmicky.

“I can’t help but think it’s an odd combination to have bitmap/pixelated fonts and graphics inside perfect squircles… two distinct ideas of a visual identity completely at odds.” – osnxkwmxkwnd
“I don't like 'us vs others' kinda comparisons, it's just marketing trick… Furthermore who needs a gamified VPN tool?” – nalekberov

🚀 Project Ideas

Generating project ideas…

AnonID – Email‑less Account Service for VPNs

Summary

  • Provides a cryptographically‑based, anonymous account system that replaces email signup with a random account number and optional recovery seed.
  • Enables VPN providers to offer true privacy‑first onboarding while still supporting account recovery and billing integrations.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Privacy‑focused VPN users and VPN providers seeking anonymous authentication
Core Feature Generates a unique, random account ID (public key) and optional mnemonic recovery phrase; no email or personal data stored
Tech Stack Rust backend (Actix‑web), WebAssembly frontend, libp2p for decentralized ID storage, Sodium libs for crypto
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue-ready: SaaS pricing per provider (tiered by active accounts)

Notes

  • HN commenters repeatedly asked for “no email + randomized account number flow” (john_strinlai, iAMkenough); AnonID directly satisfies that demand.
  • By removing a central email database, VPN services reduce a single point of failure and increase trust, addressing concerns raised about reliance on partner infrastructure.

MultiHop VPN Orchestrator

Summary

  • A client‑side orchestrator that lets users compose, test, and fail‑over across multiple VPN providers (e.g., Mullvad, Obscura, custom WireGuard nodes) in a configurable multi‑hop chain.
  • Improves reliability and mitigates the risk of a single provider shutting down or being compromised.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Power users, privacy enthusiasts, and tech‑savvy individuals who use multiple VPN services
Core Feature Dynamic multi‑hop routing with health checks, automatic failover, and a simple UI to reorder hops
Tech Stack Go or Rust core (WireGuard bindings), optional Tauri GUI, Prometheus‑style health endpoints, TOML config
Difficulty High
Monetization Hobby (open‑source) – can later offer premium support or cloud‑managed orchestration as Revenue‑ready: subscription

Notes

  • Commenters worried about “single point of failure for this product is Mullvad” (iAMkenough) and wanted a way to avoid relying on one provider; MultiHop offers redundancy.
  • The ability to combine providers also satisfies the desire expressed by users who see little added value in a single VPN over Mullvad (maxloh) by letting them craft personalized privacy paths.

Cohesive UI Kit for Privacy Apps

Summary

  • A design system and component library tailored for privacy‑focused applications (VPNs, encrypted messengers, etc.) that ensures visual harmony—avoiding clashes like bitmap fonts versus squircles.
  • Offers pre‑built, accessible UI elements (buttons, toggles, forms) with light/dark themes and optional pixel‑art or smooth‑icon variants.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Indie developers, product designers, and startup teams building privacy‑oriented software
Core Feature Unified UI kit (React/Vue/Svelte) with Figma components, theme tokens, and accessibility guidelines
Tech Stack TypeScript, Storybook, TailwindCSS (or CSS‑modules), Vitest for testing
Difficulty Low
Monetization Hobby (MIT‑licensed) – optional premium theme packs as Revenue‑ready: one‑time purchase

Notes

  • Several HN remarks pointed out the jarring mix of “bitmap/pixelated fonts and graphics inside perfect squircles” (osnxkwmxkwnd); this kit gives designers a cohesive visual language to avoid such mismatches.
  • By providing a ready‑made, privacy‑themed UI, teams can focus on core security features rather than reinventing basic design, leading to faster iteration and higher user trust—a point appreciated by commenters valuing good design and usability (dorongrinstein).

Read Later