IdeaWell

Project ideas from Hacker News discussions.

Oh My Zsh adds bloat

Original Article

Hacker News Discussion

📝 Discussion Summary (Click to expand)

1. OMZ Bloat and Slow Startup

Many criticize Oh My Zsh for excessive startup latency (e.g., 380ms), urging lighter configs.
"I removed it, then continued using Zsh... The whole process took under an hour." - latexr
"OMZ adds bloat... affects shell startup time." - author (implied via discussion)

2. Praise for Fish Shell

Users laud Fish's out-of-box interactive features, syntax, and speed, despite non-POSIX scripting.
"The baseline fish experience is just better." - paulirish
"Fish is just excellent out of the box." - Hammershaft

3. Lighter Zsh Alternatives (Starship, Zim, etc.)

Recommendations for fast prompts like Starship, Zimfw, Prezto, or zsh4humans over OMZ.
"Try https://starship.rs then. Starship gives you the same 'drop in and go' experience but without the 200ms+ prompt lag." - FrenchTouch42
"You can use something like zim that is better than omz but still easy." - tcoff91

4. Convenience and Workflow Tradeoffs

Some defend OMZ for ease/productivity; others prioritize minimalism or reuse terminals.
"I can get a good shell experience out of the box and immediately start working... single command to install oh-my-zsh." - g947o
"any time spent tinkering with the shell is a waste of time: a basic, zero-customization bash is just as good." - bigstrat2003

🚀 Project Ideas

ShellScout Profiler

Summary

  • A diagnostic tool focused on detecting and fixing "shell startup bloat"—specifically targeting common offenders like nvm, rvm, and global plugin managers.
  • It provides a breakdown of exactly what is slowing down the terminal (in milliseconds) and suggests modular, lazy-loading replacements.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Developers with "terminal-centric" workflows who open hundreds of tabs.
Core Feature Startup profiling with automated "Lazy-Load" code generation for NVM/asdf.
Tech Stack Rust or Go (for zero-dependency speed) + Shell Script shims.
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Hobby

Notes

  • "Holy heck, I just profiled my zsh initialization and nvm was the big source of bloat... lazy loading it fixes it." — prodigycorp
  • This solves the frustration of users who like the features of NVM or OMZ but can't stand the 400ms+ delay.

Starship Preset Marketplace (or "Starship Wizard")

Summary

  • A visual configuration tool and community marketplace for Starship prompts.
  • Solves the steep learning curve and lack of "wizard" experience found in Powerlevel10k, while fixing the issue of "empty segments" the community complained about.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Users who want a "cool" shell without learning TOML or escape codes.
Core Feature GUI for building prompts and one-click "Theme" exports.
Tech Stack Next.js (Web Frontend) + Rust (CLI tool).
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue-ready: SaaS for "cloud-synced" prompt profiles.

Notes

  • "Powerlevel10k has an interactive wizard... but Starship makes you manually write escape codes." — Zarel
  • HN users clearly want the speed of Starship but miss the "out of the box" beauty of OMZ.

Dotfile Porter (AI-Native)

Summary

  • A service that uses LLMs (specialized Claude/GPT wrappers) specifically to port legacy .bashrc or Oh-My-Zsh configs to "Lean" Zsh, Fish, or Nushell.
  • Instead of just a general chat, it parses local files, benchmarks the result, and guarantees "muscle memory" by porting specific aliases and git plugins.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Long-time Zsh/Bash users with "10+ years of configs" afraid to switch.
Core Feature Automated translation of shell-specific aliases and logic to new shells.
Tech Stack Python, LLM APIs (Claude 3.5 Sonnet highly recommended for coding).
Difficulty Low
Monetization Revenue-ready: Pay-per-migration or "Pro" dev-environment setup tool.

Notes

  • "I used Claude code and have removed the OMZ config within 5 minutes... might be missing functionality I'll realize later." — asadjb
  • Users are already doing this manually; a dedicated tool that validates the logic would be a high-conversion utility product.

Read Later