IdeaWell

Project ideas from Hacker News discussions.

On Being a Human Being in the Time of Collapse (2022) [pdf]

Original Article

Hacker News Discussion

📝 Discussion Summary (Click to expand)

Summary of Hacker News Discussion Themes

The discussion centers on three prevalent themes: the tension between technical education and ethical responsibility, critiques of technological impact and industry complicity, and debates over societal and democratic crises.

1. The Role of Education: Job Training vs. Societal Reflection

A central conflict emerged over whether universities should prioritize job readiness or foster broader ethical and societal reflection, especially in engineering disciplines. Many argued that technical education lacks humanities, leading to a workforce ill-equipped for moral complexities.

"College is under-optimized for the individual because its purpose is to optimize for society as a whole." (npunt) "The kind of bigger picture discussion that this lecture is doing is especially important in engineering disciplines since they don't focus much on humanities..." (npunt) "We might live in a different world if a little more 'why' had been introduced into the 'what' and 'how' of eng education." (npunt)

2. Tech Industry's Role in Global Crises and Ethical Complicity

There was significant discussion about the moral responsibility of those in technology, with some acknowledging their part in societal harms and others questioning the premise of collapse. This led to debates on personal agency versus systemic critique.

"Everyone working in tech right now plays a part in a lot of horrors haunting the world right now, and all of us are partly guilty." (9dev) "If your answer to this is, 'I don't care about the environment... as long as I get a good salary'—that's a valid answer for sure..." (9dev) "Then I switch back to objectively how humanity has been historically and how far we have come, I can't stop thinking, 'wow'." (tomaytotomato) "My engineer brain says lets pick up the poo and then look at solutions to stop it happening again." (tomaytotomato)

3. Societal Instability, Democracy, and Media Manipulation

Users debated whether modern democracies are in crisis, citing polarization, propaganda, and structural failures. The causes ranged from economic inequality and housing shortages to targeted misinformation campaigns that exploit real grievances.

"Pretty much all western countries are experiencing a crisis of democracy. It seems to me that the biggest contributor to this is the vulnerability of the electorate." (grunder_advice) "Propaganda always builds on real greviences that the electorate has." (grunder_advice) "There’s class warfare, all right, but it’s my class, the rich class, that’s making war, and we’re winning." (Warren Buffet, cited by arethuza) "The Overton window isn't shifting. It's shattering." (AnimalMuppet)

🚀 Project Ideas

[Engineering Ethics & Impact Explorer]

Summary

  • [A web-based tool that helps engineers and students map the second- and third-order societal, environmental, and political impacts of their technical decisions and career choices.]
  • [Instead of abstract lectures, it provides a structured framework to visualize consequences, compare personal values with potential project impacts, and explore alternative career paths with positive real-world outcomes.]

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Software engineers, CS students, and tech professionals feeling ethically unaligned or seeking purpose-driven work.
Core Feature An interactive decision tree and impact visualization dashboard. Users input a technology stack (e.g., ad-tech algorithm, social media feed) and receive a detailed breakdown of potential externalities (e.g., polarization, environmental cost, labor displacement).
Tech Stack React/Next.js, TypeScript, Prisma, PostgreSQL, D3.js or Recharts for visualizations.
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Hobby (Open Source initially, potential for premium enterprise modules for CSR reporting).

Notes

  • [Directly addresses the sentiment in the thread: "It seems to me that our democracies would be much healthier without embellished fake new narratives" and the desire for engineers to solve problems rather than "just acknowledge them."]
  • [Practical utility for students navigating the "optimization for job readiness" vs. "broader world" conflict mentioned by npunt. It serves as a structured alternative to reading moral philosophy papers in isolation.]

[Civic Infrastructure Visualizer]

Summary

  • [A data visualization platform that aggregates local and national data on housing, energy, and infrastructure to objectively show the gaps between political rhetoric and physical reality.]
  • [It pulls datasets on housing starts, energy production, and transportation usage, overlaying them with legislative outcomes to provide a "reality check" on political claims, addressing the frustration with unaddressed physical problems vs. propaganda.]

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Voters, civic activists, and policy advocates frustrated by misinformation regarding housing shortages, energy crises, and infrastructure decay.
Core Feature A "Civic Health Index" map. Users can zoom into a specific region to see real-time metrics on housing stock vs. population, energy grid capacity, and public transport updates, contrasted against current political promises.
Tech Stack Python (Django/Flask), Mapbox GL JS, GeoPandas, React, D3.js.
Difficulty High (Data acquisition and cleaning are the major hurdles).
Monetization Revenue-ready: Freemium model for detailed historical analysis, with free access to current local data. Selling aggregated insights to news outlets or NGOs.

Notes

  • [Addresses GardenLetter27's point: "Western governments have been mostly incapable of building housing and infrastructure."]
  • [Provides a tool to cut through the "propaganda" and "embellished fake news" mentioned by grunder_advice, focusing on tangible physical metrics rather than political narratives.]

[Socratic Debate Simulator]

Summary

  • [A lightweight SaaS tool for engineering teams and classrooms to practice discussing contentious ethical dilemmas without falling into binary traps or emotional arguments.]
  • [It uses LLMs to moderate debates, prompting users to argue from different perspectives (including opposing views) to foster empathy and break the "operate in absolutes" mindset identified in the discussion.]

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Engineering teams, university ethics committees, and students looking to improve soft skills and critical thinking.
Core Feature Role-playing simulation. Users are assigned a viewpoint (e.g., "Pro-innovation techno-optimist," "Cautious environmentalist") and must debate a topic (e.g., AI regulation, nuclear energy) using evidence and logic, penalized for ad hominem attacks or logical fallacies.
Tech Stack Node.js, OpenAI API (or local LLM), WebSockets for real-time interaction, Tailwind CSS.
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue-ready: SaaS subscription per active user seat, with bulk discounts for educational institutions.

Notes

  • [Addresses the friction in the thread, such as the exchange between OKRainbowKid and bratbag about "operating in absolutes" vs. "analysis paralysis."]
  • [Offers a constructive outlet for the "reflective" side of the lecture discussion, allowing for the "messy ideas among a menu of disciplines" that npunt values without the stress of a formal lecture.]

[Local Action Network Builder]

Summary

  • [A matchmaking and project management platform specifically for connecting technical talent with local community organizations focused on tangible problems like housing, environmental cleanup, and digital literacy.]
  • [It connects the "Dog poo dilemma" engineering mindset (solving immediate problems) with the need for civic engagement, filtering out abstract political discourse in favor of hands-on help.]

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Engineers seeking meaningful local impact, neighborhood associations, and non-profits lacking technical resources.
Core Feature Skill-based matching and project scoping. Non-profits post specific technical needs (e.g., "Database for food bank," "GIS mapping for zoning issues"). Engineers browse and commit to discrete "sprints" to solve them.
Tech Stack Ruby on Rails (or Django), React Native (for mobile use on site), Stripe Connect (for micro-donations to projects).
Difficulty Medium (Network effects are the biggest challenge).
Monetization Hobby (Donation-based, taking a small percentage of funds raised for specific projects).

Notes

  • [Directly implements the "pick up the poo and then look at solutions" philosophy of tomaytotomato, turning civic frustration into actionable engineering tasks.]
  • [Addresses the feeling of helplessness described by jijijijij regarding self-efficacy, providing concrete evidence of changing the local world for the better.]

Read Later