Premature Release and Embargo Failure
Many users criticized how news outlets published articles about the model's release before OpenAI's official blog post was live, highlighting a breakdown in the embargo process.
"paxys: Shows the weirdness of online journalism. News outlets were briefed about an upcoming event and pre-wrote and scheduled articles. When the time came they were all triggered. Except...the event didn't actually happen."
"tosh: not released yet"
"gadtfly: It seems like these articles might have come out prematurely, tbd by how much."
Skepticism About AGI Claims
Widespread doubt surrounded OpenAI's framing of GPT-6 Astra as artificial general intelligence, with users debating the definition and accusing the company of moving goalposts.
"qsera: AGI my ass!"
"ncr100: If Sam Altman had said it, I'd have reason to believe that it was a lie.... But since this other guy at Open AI said it, it must be the truth."
"HarHarVeryFunny: It's not moving the goalposts - it's just having a different goal in the first place."
Criticism of Marketing Hype
Commenters frequently denounced the release as overhyped marketing, arguing the promotional language exaggerated the model's capabilities and significance.
"geooff_: Jesus so much marketing slop - release it don't"
"famouswaffles: Coding was solved in 2023. The world ended with the release of Mythos. Now AGI has definitely been created. I like LLMs and use them every day but these people need to stop this hyperbole."
"voxleone: >>He ended the briefing by saying: 'Welcome to the AGI era.' That's pathetic. Why do people keep doing this?"
Limited Initial Availability
Users noted the model was initially restricted to select organizations despite being announced broadly, creating frustration about access discrepancies.
"jodacola: From the article: > GPT-6 Astra will first be available to a limited set of organizations in OpenAI's Daybreak Access program and will be available 'in the coming days' for ChatGPT Plus, Pro, Business and Enterprise customers and API developers."
"asaddhamani: So not a single normal human being can access the model yet, just some super limited handful of organizations, but theyâve announced the model as though itâs available to everyone already."
"pseudosavant: Select orgs first, as in today. They said it will roll out to all of the paying consumers and businesses over the next few days."