IdeaWell

Project ideas from Hacker News discussions.

Over 40% of deceased drivers in vehicle crashes test positive for THC: Study

Original Article

Hacker News Discussion

📝 Discussion Summary (Click to expand)

1. THC Presence ≠ Driving Impairment

Skepticism that high THC levels prove causation, due to persistence in habitual users and poor correlation with impairment like BAC for alcohol.
"THC in the blood doesn’t mean actively high for habitual users" (meroes).
"There’s no reliable way to determine impairment from a blood test" (Ancapistani).

2. Need for Baseline Population Data

Calls for THC prevalence in general drivers/population to contextualize 40% rate in fatalities.
"I am curious what percentge of the general populous test positive for THC. It would give better context" (neoCrimeLabs).
"If 40% of people test positive for THC, then this would mean there is no effect" (watwut).

3. Post-Legalization/COVID Reckless Driving & Enforcement Failures

Anecdotes of more public THC use, stoned driving, and broader lawlessness; demands for harsher penalties on repeat offenders.
"I see people smoking and vaping at stoplights all the time... far more of this... since legalization" (SilverElfin).
"The United States could dramatically improve its road safety if it kept maybe 1-3% of its drivers off the road permanently" (spamizbad).

🚀 Project Ideas

Traffic Fatality Baseline Analyzer

Summary

  • Web dashboard aggregating public crash data, THC/alcohol positivity rates in fatalities vs. general driving population baselines (e.g., roadside surveys), pre/post-legalization trends, and confounders like age/SES.
  • Core value: Provides context to raw stats like "40% THC-positive dead drivers" by visualizing baselines and controls, enabling informed debate.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Researchers, policymakers, HN users debating studies
Core Feature Interactive queries/filtering on datasets (NHTSA, state DMVs) with stats like % THC in random drivers vs. fatalities
Tech Stack React + D3.js frontend, PostgreSQL backend, Python (Pandas/Statsmodels) for analysis
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Hobby

Notes

  • Addresses "I am curious what percentge of the general populous test positive for THC. It would give better context" (neoCrimeLabs) and "we need a control population" (SecretDreams).
  • High discussion potential as open-source tool for verifying anecdotes like post-COVID lawlessness.

THC-Specific Field Sobriety App

Summary

  • Mobile app using phone sensors (accelerometer, camera AR) for standardized impairment tests (reaction time, tracking, divided attention) calibrated against THC tolerance studies, with self-logging for personal baselines.
  • Core value: Reliable, objective alternative to blood tests, helping users assess "am I safe to drive?" beyond blood THC levels.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience THC users, law enforcement for preliminary screening
Core Feature Guided tests with scoring vs. user baseline; exportable reports for DREs
Tech Stack Flutter/React Native, ML Kit for gaze tracking, Firebase for user data
Difficulty High
Monetization Revenue-ready: Freemium (basic free, pro $4.99/mo)

Notes

  • Solves "we lack an agreed-upon, time-linked impairment metric comparable to BAC" (ModernMech) and "until we have a valid method of testing if someone is 'too stoned to drive'" (reactordev).
  • HN loves practical safety tools; could spark validation studies.

Repeat Offender Tracker SaaS

Summary

  • Cloud service for municipalities integrating camera/ALPR data to auto-track repeat violations (speeding, reds), apply exponential fines/points, flag for suspension, with public dashboard for transparency.
  • Core value: Enforces escalating penalties on the "1-3% of drivers" causing chaos without manual cop work.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience City traffic depts, DMVs
Core Feature ALPR ingestion, violation scoring with decay/escalation logic, automated notifications/impounds
Tech Stack Node.js + AWS (Rekognition for plates), MongoDB, serverless lambdas
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue-ready: SaaS ($10k+/yr per city)

Notes

  • Tackles "drivers who get 30+ speed camera tickets... 50x as likely to crash" (macNchz) and "exponential punishment... severely punish the small anti-social group" (turbobrew).
  • Utility for real-world enforcement; HN would debate/privacy implications.

Read Later