Top 3 Themes from the HN thread
| # | Theme | Supporting quote |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Success is driven by who you know (nepotism / cronyism) | “Pointing out that cronyism/nepotism is giving the largest boost for one’s success instead of ‘meritocracy’ is pretty depressing…” – storus |
| 2 | Birth‑circumstance and inherited privilege open doors | “The contempt for nepotism saddens me. My family’s financial fortunes (and social standing) were completely reset a few decades back…” – elevation |
| 3 | The study’s causal claim is doubtful; success is a mix of luck, effort and network | “In other words: the side effect of making more money is that you have more money to spend on your children’s education.” – cobbzilla |
These three ideas dominate the discussion: personal connections and nepotism, the advantage conferring from one’s socioeconomic origins, and skepticism toward simplistic causal narratives that ignore the intertwined role of luck, hard work, and inherited opportunity.