Project ideas from Hacker News discussions.

Things Unix can do atomically (2010)

📝 Discussion Summary (Click to expand)

Three prevailing themes

Theme What the community is saying Representative quotes
Symlink‑based deployment & locking Users praise the simplicity of swapping a symlink to switch releases, roll back, or lock resources. “Still use php deployer each day and works with symlinks as well.” – 10us
“Worked pretty well in production systems… new symlink & php graceful restart.” – atmosx
Comparisons to other tools & OS update patterns The discussion links symlink tricks to legacy tools (Capistrano, Stow, Nix) and modern OS OTA mechanisms (Android, Chrome). “Ah, the memories of capistrano, complete with zero‑downtime unicorn handover.” – lloeki
“I really liked stow. My toy distro back in the day was based on it.” – bandrami
“Android does use snapshots: https://source.android.com/docs/core/ota/virtual_ab.” – LiamPowell
Limits of atomic filesystem operations Participants note that rename, renameat2, and transactional APIs are often single‑file or OS‑specific, and that true multi‑object transactions are hard to achieve. “Even though it can do some things atomically, it only does with one file at a time, and race conditions are still possible.” – zzo38computer
“Windows had APIs for this sort of thing added in Vista, but they're now deprecating it ‘due to its complexity and various nuances which developers need to consider’.” – ptx
“Title says Unix, renameat2 is Linux‑only.” – oguz‑ismail2

🚀 Project Ideas

Generating project ideas…

AtomicFS

Summary

  • A cross‑platform library that lets developers perform atomic multi‑file transactions (rename, swap, delete, create) with a single API call.
  • Provides a simple, safe abstraction for zero‑downtime deployments, config updates, and distributed locking without relying on OS‑specific features.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience DevOps engineers, sysadmins, developers who need reliable file‑system atomicity.
Core Feature AtomicTransaction API that queues file operations and commits them atomically using renameat2, symlinks, or temporary staging.
Tech Stack Rust (or Go) for low‑level syscalls, optional C bindings, CLI wrapper, documentation in Rustdoc/GoDoc.
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Hobby

Notes

  • 0xbadcafebee praised ln atomicity; AtomicFS gives a higher‑level API that covers more cases.
  • exac’s frustration about symlink deployments is addressed by providing rollback and health‑check hooks.
  • The tool would satisfy users like gib444 who want “anything less than a new k8s cluster” to be “amateur hour”.
  • Practical utility: can be dropped into CI pipelines for atomic releases, or used as a library in custom tooling.

Read Later