IdeaWell

Project ideas from Hacker News discussions.

What does " 2>&1 " mean?

Original Article

Hacker News Discussion

📝 Discussion Summary (Click to expand)

1. The “why” behind 2>&1 – low‑level mechanics vs muscle memory
Many users explain the syntax in terms of the underlying dup2() call, while others treat it as a learned shorthand.

“2>&1 is into the file descriptor pointed to by 1, and at the time any reasonable programmer would have known that fd 1 == STDOUT.” – WJW
“The distinction between file descriptors and regular files trips up many people at first. Recognizing that & signifies a file descriptor clears up the confusion about the syntax.” – hrmtst93837
“I found the explanation useful, about why it is that way.” – ElijahLynn

2. Practical value of redirecting stderr to stdout
The pattern is used for logging, debugging, and piping output from tools that emit errors to stderr.

“Humans used this combination extensively for decades too. I'm no aware of any other simple way to grep both stdout and stderr from a process.” – WhyNotHugo
“I have used this in the past when building shell scripts and Makefiles to orchestrate an existing build system.” – jez
“It was a trick you can use if you've got a super chatty script or set of scripts, you want to silence or slurp up all of their output, but you still want to allow some mechanism for printing directly to the terminal.” – jez

3. The shell’s terse, sometimes opaque syntax – a source of frustration
Users debate whether the syntax is intuitive, a relic of early Unix, or a barrier for newcomers.

“Shell syntax is anything but simple or logical.” – phailhaus
“I think the shell author needed some way to distinguish file descriptor 1 from a file named “1” (note that 2>1 means to write stderr to the file named “1”), and ‘&’ was one of the few available characters.” – jibal
“The shell syntactical sugars also have some weird gotchas.” – goku12

4. Learning resources and the role of LLMs vs human help
Participants point to manuals, shellcheck, and the limitations of AI-generated answers.

“The Redirections section of the manual is just seven US Letter pages.” – simoncion
“Shellcheck catches lots of things and shall really make your Bash scripts better.” – TacticalCoder
“I love that this situation occured.” – ifh‑hn (highlighting the confusion that still exists even with modern tools)
“I think it’s a reminder of how archaic the systems we use are.” – amelius

These four themes capture the bulk of the discussion: the mechanics of the syntax, its real‑world utility, the frustration it can cause, and the tools (manuals, linters, LLMs) people use to master it.

🚀 Project Ideas

Visual Redirection Builder

Summary

  • A web‑based drag‑and‑drop editor that lets users map stdout, stderr, and custom file descriptors to files, pipes, or other processes.
  • Generates the exact bash syntax (2>&1, |&, 3>, etc.) and shows the execution order.
  • Solves the confusion around 2>&1, pipe ordering, and multi‑level logging.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience System administrators, DevOps engineers, shell script writers, students learning Unix
Core Feature Graphical mapping of I/O streams → automatic bash command generation and real‑time syntax preview
Tech Stack React + D3.js for UI, Node.js backend for syntax validation, Docker for sandboxed execution
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue‑ready: subscription for premium templates and team collaboration

Notes

  • HN commenters lament “I don’t know where to look” and “2>&1 is confusing”. A visual tool directly addresses this pain.
  • The tool can export scripts, highlight common pitfalls, and integrate with Shellcheck for linting.
  • Discussion potential: “Would a GUI help new users avoid the 2>&1 vs 2>1 mix‑up?”

Declarative Logging Wrapper

Summary

  • A lightweight CLI wrapper (logwrap) that lets users declare logging levels and destinations in a single command line.
  • Handles multi‑level logging, duplicate streams, and automatic rotation without manual fd gymnastics.
  • Eliminates the need for complex 2>&1 > file patterns.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Build engineers, CI/CD pipeline authors, developers writing shell scripts
Core Feature logwrap --stdout log.txt --stderr log.txt --level debug --rotate 5 automatically sets up fd redirections and rotation
Tech Stack Go (for performance and static binaries), logrotate integration, optional Docker image
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue‑ready: freemium with paid rotation and analytics add‑ons

Notes

  • Users like post‑it and jez need to capture different log levels; this tool abstracts that complexity.
  • “I want just important non‑error logs to go to the console or journal, and then those plus verbose logs to a file” – exactly what logwrap offers.
  • Practical utility: reduces script length, improves readability, and prevents ordering bugs.

FD‑Pass Wrapper

Summary

  • A command‑line utility (fdpass) that transparently passes open file descriptors to child processes via environment variables or /dev/fd paths.
  • Enables tools that normally only accept filenames (e.g., curl, gpg) to receive data from pipes or sockets.
  • Simplifies advanced use cases like passing headers to curl or status output to gpg.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Advanced shell users, security engineers, developers building pipelines
Core Feature fdpass --fd 3 --cmd "curl --dump-header /dev/fd/3 https://example.com" automatically opens /dev/fd/3 and injects it
Tech Stack Rust (for safety), POSIX APIs, optional Go wrapper for scripting
Difficulty High
Monetization Hobby (open source)

Notes

  • Addresses frustration from stabbles and gnabgib about lacking a clean way to dump headers or status streams.
  • Provides a unified interface for any program that can read from a file descriptor, expanding the ecosystem of tools that can be composed.
  • Discussion hook: “Why do we still need workarounds like 3>&1 >/dev/null?”

Shell‑Redirection DSL & Transpiler

Summary

  • A domain‑specific language (redir) that uses natural syntax (stderr -> stdout, stdout & stderr -> file.txt) to describe redirections.
  • A transpiler converts DSL scripts into portable bash, zsh, or PowerShell code.
  • Includes a linter that flags common ordering mistakes and suggests idiomatic patterns.

Details

Key Value
Target Audience Shell script authors, educators, cross‑platform developers
Core Feature Declarative redirection statements, automatic ordering, multi‑platform output
Tech Stack Python (parser with lark), Node.js for CLI, optional VS Code extension
Difficulty Medium
Monetization Revenue‑ready: paid IDE extension and enterprise support

Notes

  • Responds to comments like “I want a clearer syntax than 2>&1” and “Why not &2>&1?”.
  • Makes learning redirection intuitive; students can write stderr -> stdout and see the generated bash.
  • Practical utility: reduces bugs from misordered redirects and improves script readability across teams.

Read Later